Today In History logo TIH

James Braid begins a skeptical investigation of mesmerism

On November 13, 1841, Manchester surgeon James Braid attended a demonstration by Charles Lafontaine. Braid later wrote that this first encounter did not overcome his skepticism. Subsequent observations and experiments led him toward an explanation based on attention and bodily processes, helping separate hypnotism from claims of an invisible magnetic force.

James Braid begins a skeptical investigation of mesmerism

Did Braid become convinced at the first demonstration?

His own account separates the first visit from the observation that changed his inquiry.

Read what happened →

No. Braid said the November 13 demonstration left his existing doubts intact. At another performance six nights later, a subject’s inability to open his eyelids caught his attention. He then investigated the effect through further observation and experiments. Braid did not accept Lafontaine’s explanation of a magnetic influence passing from operator to subject. He sought a different account of how focused attention and physical conditions could produce the observed state. The first attendance began the sequence; it should not be compressed into an instant conversion or the immediate creation of a finished theory.

There’s more to this story.

Checking your daily story access…

Unlock the full story → Already a member? Sign in
Sources & context · 2
  1. James Braid: Braid on Hypnotism, reprinting the 1843 account ↗
  2. James Braid: Neurypnology (1843), Medical Heritage Library scan ↗
What else happened on November 13? →