Today In History logo TIH

Paine turns a military retreat into an argument for continued commitment

On December 19, 1776, the Pennsylvania Journal printed the first American Crisis essay by Thomas Paine. A pamphlet followed later that month. Written amid the Revolution’s military reverses, it challenged readers to treat hardship as a reason for sustained commitment, rather than evidence that the independence cause should be abandoned.

Paine turns a military retreat into an argument for continued commitment

How did Paine turn bad military news into a call to keep going?

He did not need to deny that the situation was dangerous. His argument changed what readers should conclude from that danger.

Read what happened →

Paine contrasted support offered in easy times with commitment maintained during a crisis. In his argument, retreat and hardship tested sincerity; they did not prove the cause worthless. He also challenged panic by describing resources and opportunities that remained. The essay therefore worked on morale and judgment as well as political principle. It asked readers to interpret a setback without surrendering the possibility of action. That was an act of persuasion, not evidence that victory was guaranteed or that words alone would supply, organize and lead an army. Its force lay in connecting endurance with choices still available.

There’s more to this story.

Checking your daily story access…

Unlock the full story → Already a member? Sign in
Sources & context · 3
  1. ThomasPaine:TheAmericanCrisis,NumberI ↗
  2. PennLibraries:AmericanCrisisNumberI,rarebookcatalogue ↗
  3. MoncureConwayeditor:WritingsThomasPaine,Vol1 ↗
What else happened on December 19? →