December 17, 1862 · Events
Grant’s order turns a trade problem into collective punishment
On December 17, 1862, Union general Ulysses S. Grant ordered Jews expelled from his military department within twenty-four hours. He framed the measure as enforcement against illegal trade. Its terms instead targeted an entire religious community. Jewish protests reached President Abraham Lincoln, whose intervention brought an order to revoke it.

What made Grant’s order different from action against individual smugglers?
The order did not require proof that a particular person had broken a trading rule. It treated Jewish identity as sufficient grounds for expulsion.
Read what happened →
Grant faced genuine difficulties regulating the wartime cotton trade, including speculation and misconduct by people with access to the army. His order responded by blaming Jews as a class and requiring their removal, rather than establishing individual violations. That made families with no demonstrated connection to illegal trading subject to punishment because of religion. Protesters challenged the order as an attack on their rights, and Lincoln directed that it be revoked through the military chain of command. The distinction is between enforcing a rule against a person’s conduct and turning a group identity into a presumption of guilt.
There’s more to this story.
Checking your daily story access…
Unlock the full story → Already a member? Sign in