Today In History logo TIH

Celestine V gives up the papacy, but leaves a lasting precedent

On December 13, 1294, Celestine V resigned the papacy at Naples after a brief, troubled pontificate. The former hermit had first clarified that a pope could freely leave office. His departure opened the way for a successor and helped preserve resignation as a possibility within the Church’s legal tradition.

Celestine V gives up the papacy, but leaves a lasting precedent

How could Celestine resign an office that had no higher earthly authority?

Leaving the papacy raised a problem beyond personal reluctance: who could accept the resignation of the Church’s highest officeholder?

Read what happened →

Celestine addressed the uncertainty through papal authority itself. After consulting the cardinals, he declared that the Roman pontiff could freely resign. He then gave up the office on December 13, 1294, leaving the cardinals able to elect another pope. His successor, Boniface VIII, preserved that ruling in the Liber Sextus, a major collection of canon law. The crucial distinction was between a pope choosing to leave office and a superior removing him. Celestine’s act therefore concerned both his own capacity to govern and the legal continuity of the institution after his departure.

There’s more to this story.

Checking your daily story access…

Unlock the full story → Already a member? Sign in
Sources & context · 6
  1. Holy See: Celestine V ↗
  2. Catholic Encyclopedia (1908): Pope St. Celestine V ↗
  3. Catholic Encyclopedia (1907): Pope Boniface VIII ↗
  4. Yale Law Library: Papal resignations — the case of Celestine V ↗
  5. Benedict XVI: Homily at Sulmona, July 4, 2010 ↗
  6. Benedict XVI: Declaratio, announced February 11, 2013 ↗
What else happened on December 13? →