Today In History logo TIH

Maʿarra’s capture leaves a record of massacre and famine

Crusading forces took Maʿarrat al-Numan in Syria in December 1098, following an assault on December 11 and occupation the next day. They massacred inhabitants, and Christian accounts also record cannibalism amid severe shortage. The sources preserve evidence of violence that cannot be reduced to a triumphant account of the campaign.

Maʿarra’s capture leaves a record of massacre and famine

Why do the crusaders’ own accounts need to be read critically?

Participant accounts can preserve evidence against their own side while still interpreting events through that side’s beliefs. Their proximity to the campaign does not make every detail or explanation equally secure.

Read what happened →

Christian chronicles themselves describe the massacre and episodes of cannibalism, so these events cannot simply be dismissed as accusations invented by enemies. But the writers differ about timing, participants and explanations, and some shape violence into a religious account of the expedition. Historians therefore compare their testimony rather than accept one complete story uncritically. Hunger helps explain conditions without excusing the killing of inhabitants, and a claim of victory does not erase victims. The key is to separate evidence for what happened from the meanings a writer wanted to attach to it.

There’s more to this story.

Checking your daily story access…

Unlock the full story → Already a member? Sign in
Sources & context · 4
  1. Gesta Francorum: Maʿarra siege and aftermath ↗
  2. Jay Rubenstein: Cannibals and Crusaders ↗
  3. Fordham Medieval Sourcebook: Siege of Antioch accounts ↗
  4. Cambridge: Crusading violence and later literary responses ↗
What else happened on December 12? →