Today In History logo TIH

A stubborn mismatch in heat measurements changes Planck’s physics

December 14, 1900 marks Planck’s public derivation of his radiation law, rather than a securely documented first discovery at home that day. The formula had appeared in October. Behind it lay a revealing problem: careful measurements of heat radiation no longer matched the theory he had hoped to defend.

A stubborn mismatch in heat measurements changes Planck’s physics

Why did better measurements matter so much to Planck’s new radiation law?

A formula could work well in one part of the spectrum and still fail elsewhere. The mismatch became visible when experiments reached longer wavelengths.

Read what happened →

Measurements by Heinrich Rubens and Ferdinand Kurlbaum showed that the established Wien formula did not describe black-body radiation across the whole spectrum. Planck could not solve that problem simply by insisting the older theory was sound. He constructed a new formula that matched the observations, then sought a derivation explaining why it worked. That second step led him to divide energy into finite elements. The sequence matters: new evidence helped force the change, while a successful fit to measurements still left a theoretical question to answer. The October formula and December derivation were connected stages, not one isolated flash.

There’s more to this story.

Checking your daily story access…

Unlock the full story → Already a member? Sign in
Sources & context · 8
  1. Max Planck: On the Theory of the Energy Distribution Law of the Normal Spectrum (1900), English translation ↗
  2. Max Planck Society: Energy in packets — What did Planck discover? ↗
  3. German Physical Society: Chronik ↗
  4. Roy J. Glauber: 100 Years of Light Quanta, Nobel lecture slides ↗
  5. Joint Quantum Institute: Planck and the Birth of Quantum Mechanics ↗
  6. American Physical Society: October 1900 — Planck’s Formula for Black Body Radiation ↗
  7. Max Planck Society: Planck’s career until1900 ↗
  8. Nobel Prize in Physics1918: official award summary ↗
What else happened on December 14? →