Today In History logo TIH

Boss Tweed returns to New York as a prisoner

William “Boss” Tweed was delivered to New York authorities on November 23, 1876, after his escape to Cuba and Spain. The former Tammany Hall leader returned aboard the U.S. warship Franklin. His capture ended a flight from custody but left the city’s struggle to recover stolen money unfinished.

Boss Tweed returns to New York as a prisoner

Why was Tweed still a prisoner after a court cut his criminal sentence?

The criminal punishment and the effort to recover stolen public funds were separate proceedings.

Read what happened →

An appeals court ruled that Tweed’s consecutive criminal sentences had been imposed unlawfully and ordered his release after the permissible term. Authorities then held him in connection with a civil action seeking recovery of millions of dollars. He could not meet the bail set in that case. His later escape therefore came from custody tied to the financial recovery effort, not from the original sentence continuing unchanged. The distinction explains both why a court victory did not free him permanently and why his return from Spain did not itself restore the missing money to New York.

There’s more to this story.

Checking your daily story access…

Unlock the full story → Already a member? Sign in
Sources & context · 4
  1. Historical Society of the New York Courts: Boss Tweed ↗
  2. Gustavus Myers: History of Tammany Hall, 1917 ↗
  3. NYC Landmarks: Tweed Courthouse designation ↗
  4. Biographical Directory of Congress: Tweed ↗
What else happened on November 23? →