Today In History logo TIH

Two elections leave Rome with rival popes

On November 22, 498, rival groups in Rome elected Symmachus and Laurentius to succeed Pope Anastasius II. Their dispute went before Theodoric, the Ostrogothic ruler of Italy. His initial decision favored Symmachus, but it did not end a struggle that divided clergy, senators and churches for years.

Two elections leave Rome with rival popes

Why did a king decide which pope could govern Rome?

Both claimants accepted arbitration from the ruler who controlled Italy.

Read what happened →

Rome had no agreed election result that both factions would accept. Symmachus and Laurentius therefore submitted their competing claims to Theodoric at Ravenna. The king favored Symmachus because his election had come first and had the larger clerical backing, according to the Catholic Encyclopedia account. That ruling supplied political enforcement for a church dispute, but it could not manufacture lasting agreement. When the conflict returned, arguments over accusations against Symmachus raised a second problem: who had authority to judge the bishop of Rome? The struggle exposed how closely ecclesiastical legitimacy and royal power were entangled.

There’s more to this story.

Checking your daily story access…

Unlock the full story → Already a member? Sign in
Sources & context · 2
  1. Catholic Encyclopedia: Pope St. Symmachus ↗
  2. Vatican State: Saint Symmachus ↗
What else happened on November 22? →