November 5, 1872 · Events
Susan B. Anthony’s ballot put citizenship on trial
On November 5, 1872, Susan B. Anthony voted in Rochester, New York, challenging women’s exclusion from the polls. Her prosecution turned on a constitutional question: did citizenship itself carry voting rights? The judge rejected that argument and directed a guilty verdict, adding a dispute over trial by jury.

Why could Anthony cast a ballot but still be prosecuted for voting?
Election officials accepted her registration and vote. Federal prosecutors nevertheless charged that she had no lawful right to vote.
Read what happened →
Acceptance at the polling place did not settle Anthony’s legal eligibility. She argued that the Fourteenth Amendment protected voting as a privilege of United States citizenship. New York restricted the vote to men, and Justice Ward Hunt held that voting qualifications remained principally a matter for the states. He also rejected her claim that a sincere belief in her right to vote meant she had not knowingly broken the law. The dispute therefore concerned both the meaning of citizenship and the legal consequences of acting on an interpretation that the court refused to accept.
There’s more to this story.
Checking your daily story access…
Unlock the full story → Already a member? Sign in