Today In History logo TIH

Genie’s case raised a question about care as well as language

On November 4, 1970, a thirteen-year-old girl known publicly as Genie entered Children’s Hospital Los Angeles after years of severe isolation and abuse. Her subsequent learning drew researchers interested in language development. The case also exposed the difficulty of protecting a vulnerable person when treatment, research and foster care overlapped.

Genie’s case raised a question about care as well as language

Why couldn’t Genie’s progress settle the question of when people can learn language?

Age was only one of several inseparable influences on her development.

Read what happened →

Researchers could observe what she learned after entering care, but they could not isolate the effects of age from years of abuse, deprivation and uncertain earlier development. She gained vocabulary and ways to communicate, while grammatical learning remained markedly limited. Those differences were important evidence, yet a single uncontrolled case could not establish a universal deadline for acquiring language. Her circumstances also made the research relationship unusually complicated: some investigators were responsible for her daily care. Scientific questions therefore had to coexist with a more immediate obligation to provide stability and protection.

There’s more to this story.

Checking your daily story access…

Unlock the full story → Already a member? Sign in
Sources & context · 4
  1. UCLA Library: David Rigler collection finding aid ↗
  2. Fromkin and colleagues: The Development of Language in Genie (1974) ↗
  3. Curtiss and colleagues: An update on the linguistic development of Genie (1975) ↗
  4. PBS NOVA: Secret of the Wild Child transcript ↗
What else happened on November 4? →