Today In History logo TIH

Jefferson and Burr tie because electors cannot name the office

On December 3, 1800, presidential electors cast ballots under rules that gave each elector two undifferentiated choices. Thomas Jefferson and his running mate Aaron Burr received 73 votes each. Their tie sent the presidency to the House of Representatives and exposed a mismatch between the Constitution’s original system and organized party tickets.

How could a presidential candidate tie with his own running mate?

The ballots did not yet distinguish a vote for president from a vote for vice president.

Read what happened →

Under the original constitutional system, electors voted for two people without assigning either vote to a particular office. Jefferson’s supporters wanted him as president and Burr as vice president, but both men received all 73 of their side’s electoral votes. The Constitution therefore treated them as tied candidates for the presidency. The House had to choose between them, voting by state delegation rather than by a simple count of representatives. The later Twelfth Amendment required separate designations for the two offices, allowing the formal ballot to reflect the party ticket’s intended order.

There’s more to this story.

Checking your daily story access…

Unlock the full story → Already a member? Sign in
Sources & context · 5
  1. Maryland State Archives — Meetings of Presidential Electors ↗
  2. National Archives —1800 Electoral College Results ↗
  3. National Archives — Tally of Electoral Votes for 1800 ↗
  4. Library of Congress — Presidential Election of 1800 resource guide ↗
  5. National Archives — The Election of 1800 ↗
What else happened on December 3? →