Today In History logo TIH

A council confronted accusations against a pope it would not judge

On December 1, 800, a council in Rome confronted accusations against Pope Leo III with Charlemagne present. The bishops declined to judge the pope, leaving an awkward problem of authority. Leo later swore an oath of innocence, and on Christmas Day he crowned the Frankish king emperor.

How could a council investigate a pope while denying that it could judge him?

Leo needed protection from his accusers, while Charlemagne faced limits to the authority he could claim over the papacy.

Read what happened →

The proceedings separated an examination of the accusations from a formal judgment over the pope. The bishops asserted that they lacked authority to judge him. Leo then offered an oath declaring his innocence, a religious act intended to remove suspicion without acknowledging a superior court. Charlemagne’s presence made the political imbalance clear: the pope relied on Frankish protection even as the council preserved the principle of papal immunity from its judgment. The settlement restored Leo’s position, but it did not produce a modern trial or an independently testable verdict on every allegation.

There’s more to this story.

Checking your daily story access…

Unlock the full story → Already a member? Sign in
Sources & context · 4
  1. Italian Art Society — Charlemagne and Leo III in 800 ↗
  2. Catholic Encyclopedia — Pope St. Leo III ↗
  3. New Catholic Encyclopedia — Leo III ↗
  4. Einhard — Life of Charlemagne ↗
What else happened on December 1? →