Today In History logo TIH

The Panama invasion removes a ruler while leaving questions that force cannot settle alone

United States forces invaded Panama on December 20, 1989, in Operation Just Cause, seeking to remove Manuel Noriega. Guillermo Endara’s government took office as the operation began, after an election annulled earlier that year. Noriega surrendered in January 1990. The military outcome left separate questions about civilian harm, sovereignty and the institutions of the new government.

The Panama invasion removes a ruler while leaving questions that force cannot settle alone

Why did removing Noriega not settle every question about the intervention?

Defeating a ruler’s forces, establishing accountable institutions and assessing harm to civilians are different tasks, even when they arise from the same operation.

Read what happened →

United States forces broke the power of the Panamanian Defense Forces, and Noriega later surrendered. But a change of leadership did not itself establish how the new police, courts and government would protect rights. Civilian deaths and destruction also required investigation, while the United Nations General Assembly condemned the intervention as a violation of sovereignty. The United States presented its own justifications, including protecting Americans and supporting the elected government. These claims and outcomes must be assessed separately. Military success establishes that force achieved certain objectives; it does not, by itself, resolve legitimacy, accountability or the quality of the institutions that follow.

There’s more to this story.

Checking your daily story access…

Unlock the full story → Already a member? Sign in
Sources & context · 5
  1. GeorgeH.W.Bush:addressannouncingmilitaryaction,20December1989 ↗
  2. USArmy:OperationJustCausehistoricalsummary ↗
  3. UNGeneralAssemblyResolution44/240 ↗
  4. AmericasWatch:HumanRightsinPost-InvasionPanama,1991 ↗
  5. HumanRightsWatch:Panama,1989worldreport ↗
What else happened on December 20? →